by Tim Polko
On the Fourth Day of Outfielders, my true love gave to me:
NL East "Prospects",
NL without PDV,
Single-Digit NL PDV,
and National Leaguers with Double-Digit PDV.
Minor League Free Agents and AAA/AA Prospects from the National League East
Atlanta Braves
Minor League Free Agents:
Michael Carter, 32, B:R, T:R. Carter's switched between the independent leagues and
AAA for the last few years. He doesn't have much power and his plate discipline will never
sustain an acceptable BA over an increased numbers of at-bats. While he has a little
speed, he'll be very lucky to even get one cup-of-coffee in the majors.
Damon Hollins, 27, B:R, T:L. Hollins was a top Atlanta hitting prospect several
years ago but his plate discipline never matured with his power. He's young enough where
he should find his way back to the majors for a few dozen more at-bats, although he'll need
to maintain at least an .800 OPS in AAA for a year or two before someone will likely give
him that opportunity.
Roberto Rivera, 24, B:S, T:R. Rivera's never made it above AA, and based on his
performance so far, I'll be surprised if he sees any more than the briefest AAA exposure.
He doesn't appear to have any power or speed potential, and his plate discipline leaves a
lot to be desired. If he's to have any shot at the majors, he'll need to learn how to use
his limited tools much more effectively, as I don't see him making much progress at the
moment.
Pedro Swann, 30, B:L, T:R. Swann's shown some power potential and decent plate
discipline for several seasons, even though he's yet to see more than two major league
at-bats. He appears to possess the ability to perform as a capable fifth outfielder, but
he'll need to catch some scout's eye to even find that much work. He'll likely hang around
AAA for several more years, and I don't think he'd really hurt you as a FAAB'd injury
replacement.
Prospects:
George Lombard, 25, B:L, T:R. Even though Lombard missed almost the entire season
with injury problems, he's very likely to make the Braves in 2002, since he's out of options
and they can use his abilities as a defensive replacement and pinch-runner. He has
significant speed potential but won't start in the majors until he learns to the strike
zone. Since he's shown no evidence of that knowledge in eight years in the minors, I have
serious doubts as to any upside above a fourth outfielder's role. Strongly consider
grabbing him for a buck or so. While his BA might hurt you in limited playing time, his
power/speed upside remains very strong, and you'll want to own him somewhere if he ever
matures into his tools.
Jason Ross, 27, B:R, T:R. His secondary statistics are much more impressive than
his normal counting numbers. His BA has always remained fairly low, but he boosted his
OBP to .387 and SLG to .481 at AA Greenville last year. He's never seen 500 AB for a full
season, so perhaps instead of grabbing another bunch of AAA lifers like this year's minor
league free agents, the Braves should let him play a full season at AAA to determine if he
deserves a 40-man roster slot. If they don't promote him after this year, he'll leave as
a minor league free agent, so Atlanta needs to find out if his power and speed flashes from
the last few seasons are real. He won't see the majors before September at the earliest,
and I have a strong feeling that he'll be moving to the above list for next year's review.
Carlos Urquiola, 21, B:L, T:R. The Braves picked him up from Arizona in June,
although he unfortunately missed the end of the year with an injury. Urquiola has never
received more than 384 at-bats in a season, and considering his SB upside, I'm not quite
sure why he hasn't played more. He's maintained a .336 career minor league average and a
.389 OBP despite appearing as a bit of a hacker. I think he has definite potential given
his age and tools, but he needs a full year at AA and a full year at AAA before he'll merit
serious considering for a roster spot. Only grab him with a very low minor league pick if
you're for some reason playing for 2004.
Florida Marlins
Minor League Free Agents:
Ben Candelaria, 26, B:L, T:R. Candelaria's finally developed some rather solid
plate discipline over the last two seasons, but this improvement appears to have arrived at
the expense of his power potential. If he can manage to combine his previous best minor
league seasons, he has a small chance to see some brief major league time. However, its
far more likely that he'll play out his career bouncing between AA and AAA, a pattern that
shouldn't leave him content if he thinks he can hit with power while occasionally walking.
Luke Wilcox, 27, B:L, T:R. Wilcox seemed to be on the way to establishing himself
as a reliable AAAA outfielder when he sort of fizzled over the last two seasons. His
plate discipline varies between acceptable and good, and he certainly has serious power
potential. He just can't seem to put his skills together, and when he manages to finally
accomplish that at AAA sometime in the next few years, he'll have a small window to impress
someone as a fifth outfielder in the majors.
Prospects:
Abraham Nunez, 21, B:S, T:R. Florida doesn't have many position prospects at the
upper levels, although Nunez retains an amazing amount of potential. He'll be a 20/20
threat from the moment he begins starting in the majors, if he can cut down on his
strikeouts enough to finally deserve that chance. While the Marlins were hoping for quicker
progress, they'll likely promote him to AAA for 2002, where his progress will determine
whether his ETA is late July of 2002 or 2004. He's definitely worth a minor league pick
due to his HR/SB upside, but be aware that his BA might really sting for a while.
Montreal Expos
Minor League Free Agents:
Ryan Thompson was included with National League Outfielders.
Kenny James, 24, B:S, T:R. James might venture outside the Expos' organization for
the first time after seven full years in the system. He doesn't have much power potential,
although he's shown incredible speed with 208 steals at a 82% success ratio that he's
maintained at the highest minor league levels. His plate discipline has been fairly solid
at AA, but he doesn't appear to have ever been given a significant shot at a full-time
job. With many clubs looking for leadoff hitters, James has a chance to establish himself
as a AAA player for years to come with the promise of a major league career with a lucky
break or two. Questions exist about his real capabilities, even though I'm impressed by
his progress over the last few years.
Jeremy Ware, 25, B:R, T:R. Another potential non-Expo for the first time, Ware owns
some power and speed tools but lacks the plate discipline necessary for success at AAA.
He'll likely bounce between the two top minor league levels for a few years until he either
decides to go dominate in the independent leagues or he finds a hitting coach to teach him
plate discipline. I don't think he has much potential at this time, and he's at least a
couple years away from the majors even if he does start showing more improvement in his
skills.
Prospects:
Geronimo Berroa, 36, B:R, T:R. Berroa still could be a decent right-handed
pinch-hitter for some teams, and certainly could play another couple years at AAA. He's
fortunate that the A's gave him the chance to succeed in the majors when many other teams
would never have given a minor league veteran close to that many at-bats. While he has a
little power potential left for the majors, even if he makes it back, his BA is too risky
for a pick-up.
Dan McKinley, 25, B:L, T:R. McKinley has a little power along with promising
speed, but his plate discipline just doesn't support his continued high BA. I have a hard
time envisioning him as anything more than a borderline major leaguer. If he gets a
call-up next season, you should probably avoid him, since his weak plate control could
wind up really hurting your average.
Ron Calloway, 24, B:L, T:L. Calloway's improved his SB% over the last couple of
years but his plate discipline suffered dramatically in 2001 as he split the year between
AA and AAA. Montreal foolishly promoted him when his .919 OPS was relatively unsupported
by a 24:46 BB:K ratio in 279 at-bats. He needs to go back and spend at least another half
season mastering AA before any more AAA exposure. He retains the potential to emerge as a
decent fourth outfielder and perhaps even a leadoff option. Teams must be more careful about
promoting prospects before they've had the chance to truly excel at a level.
Matt Cepicky, 23, B:L, T:R. Some scouts might think that Cepicky's on target to
challenge for an outfield job sometime in 2003, but plate discipline fell noticeably at AA,
leaving his OBP under .300. Even a SLG rebound to .473 doesn't excuse the fact that he
wasn't more than an average AA player, and he needs to return there for another season
until he knows how to walk to first base. Cepicky has the potential to start for a few
seasons in the majors, although it could easily go to waste if Montreal promotes him too
quickly. He needs at least two more years in the high minors.
Tootie Myers, 22, B:R, T:L. Myers is yet another toolsy outfielder, this time with
average power and speed but still without any semblance of plate discipline. He needs to
stay at AA until his strikeout rate basically drops in half, and only then will his tools
have a chance to work at AAA and above. Calloway, Cepicky, and Myers could make a solid AA
outfield, although with more prospects pushing from A-ball, I expect at least one of these
guys to find himself over-promoted and struggling to stay in the organization, probably
Calloway based on his comparatively weaker power and advanced age.
Valentino Pascucci, 22, B:R, T:R. Val is our new favorite prospect, since not only
does he have a great name, but we grabbed one of his foul balls at an AFL game and got it
autographed by him. Like seemingly every Montreal position prospect, his plate discipline
doesn't support his progress to AAA, and the Expos really need to leave him at AA for at
least a few more months. Since he's 6'6" and not particularly fast, they should probably
stick him at first base as the probable heir apparent to Lee Stevens. Pascucci has good
power potential, although he shouldn't see the majors before the second half of 2003.
New York Mets
Minor League Free Agents:
Scott Hunter, 25, B:R, T:R. Hunter has a little power and speed potential, but he's
never shown adequate command of the strike zone at any level. With plate discipline as bad
as Hunter's, he'll be lucky to maintain a AAA career. I don't see any major league
potential in his future beyond a cup-of-coffee as a defensive replacement and pinch-runner.
Juan LeBron, 24, B:R, T:R. The Mets hoped LeBron would learn enough of the strike
zone to allow development of his power stroke, but AA appears to be his limit at the
moment. His career BB:K ratio is 151:535, and without any plate discipline, he can only
crush the occasional mistake pitch. LeBron should hang around for several more years while
teams take chances on his power upside, although he won't be making any roto teams in
the foreseeable future.
Tony Tarasco, 30, B:L, T:R. Tarasco has matured into a player with extremely solid
plate discipline, some power potential, and even decent speed. He deserves the opportunity
to re-establish himself as a reserve outfielder, and I'd expect most teams to be pleasantly
surprised with his progress, even though he never played that badly in the first place.
While he doesn't have much roto upside, he could earn a couple bucks if he can find several
dozen at-bats.
Prospects:
Mike Curry, 24, B:L, T:R. Curry really disappointed me with New York after I had
very high expectations for him going into the season. I recognize that he's another guy like
Tyner without almost any power, but his plate discipline and speed skills were
excellent, and he showed the potential to develop into a great leadoff hitter. He needs to
rebound very strongly in 2002 to keep himself in the Mets' future plans, so you probably
shouldn't pick him up in anything but the deepest of minor league drafts.
Allen Dina, 27, B:R, T:R. Dina has no plate discipline, limited power, and good
speed obscured by his inability to get on base at all in the upper minors. He's unlikely
to make the majors, and he'll probably spend most of his career at AA.
Ray Montgomery, 30, B:R, T:R. Houston never gave Montgomery much of a chance to
establish himself as a reserve outfielder. While he still retains enough plate discipline
and power to potentially excel in the majors in a limited capacity, I don't expect anyone
else to give him that opportunity. Be willing to use him if you need an injury
replacement, since he's likely to maintain a respectable BA and has some power upside.
Rob Stratton, 23, B:R, T:R. 2001 AA numbers: 483 AB, 30 2B, 29 HR, 53:201
BB:K ratio. Stratton's significant power upside remains obscured by perhaps the least
plate discipline of any player in baseball. He controls the strike zone enough to walk a
decent amount, leading to acceptable OBPs considering his SLG. His challenge is to
convince AAA and major league managers that he deserves playing time despite his potential
to strike out at least once every game.
Jaisen Randolph. Milwaukee selected Randolph in the minor league portion of the
Rule Five draft. Here's what I wrote about him at the time:
Brief bio: 22, B:S, T:R. A speed freak lost from the Cubs on waivers in the middle of the
season. He's developed solid plate discipline over the last few years at a severe cost to
his batting average, apparently not making enough contact to justify the increased walk
levels. He has little power and poor baserunning instincts as indicated by a 23:19 SB:CS
ratio in AA this season. Randolph has the tools to be successful, but doesn't appear to
have the necessary skills.
Upside/ETA: 5th outfielder. 2004.
Quality of pick: Acceptable.
Philadelphia Phillies
Minor League Free Agents:
Ramon Gomez, 25, B:R, T:R. Despite excellent speed potential, Gomez neither
possesses solid plate discipline nor much power potential. He hasn't played above AA, and I
wouldn't expect him to see much above that level in the future considering his performance
to date. While he has a small chance of maturing into a big league role player, he'll
really be lucky to even still play professional baseball five years from now.
Manny Gonzalez, 25, B:S, T:R. Gonzalez has only really had success in A-ball and
the Independent leagues, and he might just want to return to the Northern League since his
AA performances have been relatively poor to date. He hasn't been able to maintain his
power and speed output against superior pitching, and his chances of ever making the majors
are extremely low.
Aaron Royster, 28, B:R, T:R. Royster's played almost exclusively at AA for most of
this minor league career, and he hasn't even been able to show average power or on-base
ability at Reading. He appears to be a capable organization player, so I'd expect him to
stay with Philly unless he somehow believes that another team would give him an undeserved
opportunity at a higher level.
Kenny Woods, 30, B:R, T:R. Woods owns solid plate discipline, doubles' power, and a
little speed potential. He'll never hit enough to warrant a large role in the majors, but
after ten relatively productive minor league years, he deserves at least a cup-of-coffee.
He was on the 1992 Olympic team, and that appears to be his most impressive accomplishment
to date.
Prospects:
Dave Francia, 26, B:L, T:L. Francia has some speed potential but will be lucky to
see more than the briefest of major league appearances. He doesn't possess either enough
power or plate discipline to warrant more time, so don't expect him to stay with the
Phillies past this season if they don't give him a shot. While he could probably help some
team in a very limited role, his upside remains low.
Marlon Byrd, 23, B:R, T:R. Finally, we arrive at the only real upper level outfield
prospect in the entire division that hasn't seen the majors. Byrd excelled at AA Reading
this year, cutting his strikeouts while increasing all his averages and stealing over
thirty bases again. He's a five-tool talent who probably needs to spend most of 2002 in
the minors to make sure his gains aren't a fluke. His excellent AFL campaign dispelled the
fears of many scouts, although some still harbor concerns about his stocky build. Most
reports that we've seen ignore any potential weight problem in favor of both his
statistical output and his actual appearance when playing baseball. Byrd seems to be a
rather complete ballplayer, and he should be near the top of any minor league draft in
2002.
Today's Fantasy Rx: Finalize your New Year's plans. Even if you're just staying
home and going to bed relatively early, you should probably determine a set course of
action. Most reports indicate that a lot of folks will be celebrating in their places this
year, so if you've ever wanted to go out but don't like huge crowds, there should still be
places available in venues near you.
Click
here to read the previous article.