by Tim Polko
I have a somewhat full schedule for you today. Here's the chart showing probable opening
day 2B and 3B, followed by my review of the minor league portion of the Rule Five draft.
I'd like to comment on some of this week's activity, but I don't really have much to add
to Jess' last several articles.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
American League |
Team |
2B |
% |
Alternative |
3B |
% |
Alternative |
AL East |
BAL |
Hairston |
80 |
Roberts |
Batista/Conine |
40/25 |
Trade/FA |
BOS |
Offerman/FA |
70 |
Stynes/Santos |
Hillenbrand |
80 |
Stynes/Trade |
NYY |
Soriano |
99 |
E.Wilson |
Ventura |
95 |
Henson |
TB |
Abernathy |
95 |
Smith/Johnson |
Huff/Sandberg |
65/25 |
Smith/FA |
TOR |
Bush/Hudson |
60/30 |
Woodward |
E.Hinske |
95 |
Woodward |
AL Central |
CHW |
Durham |
95 |
Valentin |
Crede/Valentin |
45/45 |
Liefer |
CLE |
Gutierrez |
85 |
Jol.Cabrera |
Fryman |
80 |
Branyan |
DET |
Easley |
95 |
Paquette |
Paquette |
75 |
D.Young |
KC |
Febles |
85 |
Alicea |
Randa |
95 |
Alicea |
MIN |
Rivas |
99 |
Hocking |
Koskie |
99 |
Hocking |
AL West |
ANA |
Kennedy |
95 |
Gil/Spiezio |
Glaus |
99 |
Spiezio |
OAK |
Menechino |
45 |
German/Ellis |
E.Chavez |
99 |
Saenz/Grabowski |
SEA |
FA/McLemore |
60/35 |
A.Arias |
Cirillo |
99 |
McLemore |
TEX |
M.Young |
95 |
Catalanotto |
Lamb/Perry |
45/45 |
Catalanotto |
|
National League |
Team |
2B |
% |
Alternative |
3B |
% |
Alternative |
NL East |
ATL |
M.Giles |
90 |
DeRosa/Furcal |
V.Castilla |
90 |
C.Jones/Betemit |
FLO |
L.Castillo |
99 |
A.Fox |
M.Lowell |
99 |
K.Millar |
MON |
J.Vidro |
99 |
Mordecai/Blum |
F.Tatis |
95 |
Blum/Mordecai |
NYM |
Alomar |
99 |
Relaford |
Alfonzo |
99 |
Relaford |
PHI |
M.Anderson |
99 |
Jordan/T.Perez |
Rolen |
80 |
Trade/K.Jordan |
NL Central |
CHC |
DeShields/Hill |
85/10 |
Bellhorn |
Mueller |
95 |
Bellhorn |
CIN |
T.Walker |
90 |
Reese/J.Castro |
B.Larkin |
90 |
Reese/Guerrero |
HOU |
Biggio |
99 |
Vizcaino |
Truby/Ensberg |
45/45 |
Ginter |
MIL |
R.Belliard |
85 |
Loretta |
Loretta/Houston |
55/25 |
L.Lopez/Trade |
PIT |
Meares/Morris |
45/25 |
Nunez/Benjamin |
A.Ramirez |
99 |
Benjamin |
STL |
Vina |
95 |
Polanco |
Pujols |
85 |
Polanco |
AL West |
ARI |
Counsell/J.Bell |
55/40 |
Spivey |
M.Williams |
90 |
Colbrunn |
COL |
J.Ortiz |
95 |
Butler/Shumpert |
FA/Norton |
55/25 |
Shumpert/Butler |
LA |
Grudzielanek |
85 |
Bocachica/Trade |
Beltre |
99 |
Hiatt/Hansen |
SD |
D.Jimenez |
90 |
Jackson/Crespo |
S.Burroughs |
95 |
Nevin/Crespo |
SF |
Kent |
99 |
R.E.Martinez |
Feliz/Trade |
55/15 |
R.E.Martinez/FA |
Hopefully this will help will some of your trade bait/targets. As before, if I haven't
rated a player as at least a 50% chance of starting at a particular position on Opening
Day, you probably want to look elsewhere to fill that particular position.
Rule Five Draft Review: Minor League Phase
Teams can keep their selections at any level. AAA players cost $12,000 each, and AA
players cost $4,000 each.
Triple A Round One
Tampa Bay: David Hawk, LHP, PIT.
Brief bio: 22, B:L, T:L. On disqualified list from July 22,1998-January 7, 1999. On
suspended list from June 18-October 28, 1999. He has less than 70 IP in two seasons at
low-A and Rookie ball. He's walked more than he's struck out without striking out anywhere
close to an impressive number of hitters.
Upside/ETA: Too soon to tell.
Quality of pick: Questionable.
Pittsburgh: Eddie Ramos, RHP, TEX
Brief bio: Decent season in relief in the Rookie Appalachian League, with 30:8 KK:B in
31.2 IP. No other biographical information available.
Upside/ETA: Too soon to tell.
Quality of pick: Acceptable.
Baltimore: Willy Serrano, RHP, DET
Brief bio: 20, B:R, T:R. Four years in Tiger system, with the last two at high-A Lakeland.
Significantly improved his numbers this season, with a 56:28 BB:K ratio in 82.1 IP.
Upside/ETA: Middle relief. Late 2004.
Quality of pick: Solid.
Kansas City: Tydus Meadows, OF, CHC
Brief bio: 23, B:R, T:R. Improved plate discipline to 40:57 BB:K in 197 AB at AA West
Tennessee, along with a .915 OPS in 2001. Showed solid tool in the Midwest League in 1999,
and has started to translate those into production at the upper levels. Inconsistent
strike zone judgement.
Upside/ETA: Fourth outfielder unless he can maintain growth. Late 2003.
Quality of pick: Very good.
Detroit: Chris Keelin, RHP, PHI
Brief bio: 24, B:R, T:R. A little old for the Florida State League, but still managed a
87:40 K:BB in 72 IP while allowing a miniscule 44 hits. These numbers are very similar
to his Sally league stats, a clear indication of significant promise if he can keep his
stuff under control.
Upside/ETA: Short relief. Should compete for a bullpen job in 2003.
Quality of pick: Excellent.
Milwaukee: Jaisen Randolph, OF, NYM
Brief bio: 22, B:S, T:R. A speed freak lost from the Cubs on waivers in the middle of
the season. He's developed solid plate discipline over the last few years at a severe
cost to his batting average, apparently not making enough contact to justify the increased
walk levels. He has little power and poor baserunning instincts as indicated by a 23:19
SB:CS ratio in AA this season. Randolph has the tools to be successful, but doesn't appear
to have the necessary skills.
Upside/ETA: Fifth outfielder. 2004.
Quality of pick: Acceptable.
Texas: Jeff Pickler, 2B, MIL
Brief bio: 25, B:L, T:R. Pickler had an interesting year while repeating AA Huntsville
for the third time, posting a 60:51 BB:K ratio and 34:14 SB:CS while only managing a
.687 OPS. I think he'll have some success at AAA, but he doesn't seem to have enough
power to succeed in the majors.
Upside/ETA: Utility infielder with a little speed and OBP. Mid-2003.
Quality of pick: Excellent considering that Texas lost 5 second basemen as minor league
free agents and needed to replenish system depth. A solid pick for any other team.
Colorado: Cristian Berroa, SS, HOU
Brief bio: 22, B:S, T:R. Received experience at three different levels of the minors as
an organizational fill-in. Possesses significant speed without much probable offense at
higher levels. Doesn't control the strike zone or drive the ball, and played inconsistent
defense this season.
Upside/ETA: Pinch-runner and possibly utility shortstop. 2005.
Quality of pick: Questionable.
Anaheim: Hatuey Mendoza, RHP, ARI
Brief bio: 21, B:R, T:R. Has never showed acceptable command (2 K:BB) or any above
average strikeout potential at the lower levels of the minors. He's pitched in the
Arizona system for five years without showing much progress. He can hold his own at
A-ball, but I have serious doubts as to any possibility for advancement.
Upside/ETA: AAA Innings-eater. 2005.
Quality of pick: Acceptable.
Toronto: Josh Klimek, SS, MIL
Brief bio: 27, B:L, T:R. Solid power numbers with acceptable plate discipline. Klimek is
a veteran minor leaguer to help at AA/AAA.
Upside/ETA: AAAA infielder. 2003.
Quality of pick: Solid. Toronto needed a veteran shortstop in the upper minors with all
the prospect promotions and trades.
San Diego: Lavalroe Condor Cash, OF, CHC
Brief bio: 21, B:R, T:R. He's shown solid tools in short-season ball, posting a .982
OPS in his second year in the Northwest League. He has power potential and decent plate
discipline, but hasn't had the chance to show off any other skills.
Upside/ETA: Too soon to tell.
Quality of pick: An excellent long-term gamble.
New York Mets: Omar Anez, RHP, BAL
Brief bio: 20, B:R, T:R. He's posted an ERA around 8.00 in two of his four seasons, and
while he's slowly improved over the last few years, he's still had no success above short
season A-ball.
Upside/ETA: Too soon to tell.
Quality of pick: Acceptable.
Chicago White Sox: Alex Fernandez, OF, SEA
Brief bio: 20, B:L, T:R. A solid Seattle prospect, I'm quite surprised they exposed him to
this draft. His AA numbers weren't overly special, but he continues to show progress in
both power and plate discipline, and I think he has a very good chance of turning into a
solid player.
Upside/ETA: Starting outfielder. Late 2004.
Quality of pick: Superb.
Philadelphia: Jimmy Hamilton, LHP, BAL
Brief bio: 25, B:L, T:R. Hamilton's played at AAA for most of the past three years. He
posted a combined 71:35 K:BB ratio in 85.1 IP between AAA and AA this year. His stuff
doesn't appear overly impressive, but he could probably contribute in the bullpen as
soon as next season.
Upside/ETA: Middle relief. 2003.
Quality of pick: Very good.
Minnesota: Jeromy Palki, RHP, CHC
Brief bio: 25, B:R, T:R. At AA New Britain this year, posted a 59:22 K:BB ratio with
only 50 hits in 60.1 IP. I'm not sure when Minnesota lost him to the Cubs, but they
wisely reclaimed him given the chance.
Upside/ETA: Short relief. Mid-2003.
Quality of pick: Excellent.
Los Angeles: Fernando Rijo, RHP, TEX
Brief bio: 23, B:R, T:R. He put up some very nice numbers in the Sally league, compiling
a 128:54 K:BB ratio with only 107 hits allowed in 139 IP. I'm also not sure when LA lost
him to Texas, but they also made the smart decision to reclaim him.
Upside/ETA: Bottom-of-the-rotation starter. Late-2005.
Quality of pick: Solid.
Cleveland: Brian Luderer, C, OAK
Brief bio: 22, B:R, T:R. He needs a lot more playing time before we'll know his status
as a prospect, and didn't exactly acquit himself admirably in his first full-time exposure,
lacking acceptable stats in almost every category. I'm interested to see how he performs
in his second full year at AA since his plate disicpline was fairly solid until this season.
Upside/ETA: Backup catcher. Late-2004.
Quality of pick: Good.
Chicago Cubs: Brian Tokarse, RHP, CHW
Brief bio: 26, B:R, T:R. He had an excellent year in relief for AA Birmingham even though
he should have been promoted to AAA from the beginning of the year. His 81:39 K:BB in 65.2
IP was even a significant improvement over last year's 52:28 in 42 IP. As long as his
stuff remains under control, he could have several nice years in a major league bullpen.
Upside/ETA: Middle relief. Mid-2003.
Quality of pick: Excellent.
Oakland: Graham Koonce, 1B, SD
Brief bio: 26, B:L, T:L. A former 60th round pick, Koonce excelled in his first exposure
to AA, posting a 89:83 BB:K ratio in 320 AB. His .873 OPS and only 3 errors in 83 games
at 1B and OF put him in perfect position to contribute at the upper level minors for
Oakland.
Upside/ETA: Starting 1B for a few years. 2004.
Quality of pick: Excellent.
San Francisco: Eric Herndon, RHP, ATL
Brief bio: 24, B:L, T:R. Compiled a 38:11 K:BB ratio in 44.2 IP at high-A Myrtle Beach.
He missed all of 2000 with an injury, but has rebounded to a level even above his previous
performance.
Upside/ETA: Middle relief. 2004.
Quality of pick: Very good.
Seattle: Ntema "Papy" Ndungidi, OF, BAL
Brief bio: 22, B:L, T:R. He left the AFL early last year due to some very unusual
behavior, and his prospect status diminished enough to allow him to remain available
for this portion of the draft. While he has both power and speed tools and showed good
plate discipline in A-ball, he needs to rebound after a very bad year at AA Bowie.
Ndungidi has a lot of upside but needs time to allow his skills to mature.
Upside/ETA: Starting OF. 2005.
Quality of pick: Very good.
Houston: Justin Lamber, LHP, KC
Brief bio: 25, B:R, T:L. He was demoted back to A-ball after a horrible year at AA
Wichita in 2000. He put up very similar 2001 stats to his 1999 numbers but struggled
badly upon a promotion to AA. Houston is potentially the worst possible plate for him
since they have no high-A team for him to keep his confidence, and AA Round Rock is about
the best hitters' park in the minors.
Upside/ETA: AAA middle relief. 2004.
Quality of pick: Poor.
St. Louis: Milko Jaramillo, SS, KC
Brief bio: 21, B:S, T:R. He's shown a little plate discipline and speed in rookie ball,
but doesn't appear to have any significant offensive skills for the upper levels. On the
other hand, he fits right in with the Cardinals' strategy of assembling as many useless
"prospects" as possible.
Upside/ETA: Too soon to tell.
Quality of pick: Very questionable.
Triple A Round Two
Kansas City: Freddy DePaula, LHP, OAK
Brief bio: 20, B:L, T:L. Aside from being born left-handed and striking out about a
batter per inning, I don't think DePaula has that much ability. He walks far too many
batters, a trend that has not abated over his four years of professional experience.
I hope KC sticks him back at low A-ball to allow him the chance to establish himself
before any further promotion.
Upside/ETA: LOOGY (John Sickels' term for Lefty-One-Out-GuY). Late-2005.
Quality of pick: Acceptable.
Toronto: Clint Johnston, 1B, PIT
Brief bio: 24, B:L, T:L. Stop me if this sounds familiar: Pittsburgh drafts a top power
hitter in the first round, and instead of adding another bat to a weak system, uses him
at his less-preferred position of pitcher. Despite occasional dominance, Johnston showed
very little overall control. Toronto's making a solid gamble with this pick, and while I
may be blindly accepting everything Ricciardi does right now as logical moves, this appears
to be another low-risk, high-upside move.
Upside/ETA: Too soon to tell.
Quality of pick: Excellent gamble.
Minnesota: Joe Dillon, 1B, KC
Brief bio: 25, B:R, T:R. His plate discipline fell off this year while he posted his best
power season to date while playing all around the infield. He doesn't have significant
upside, but could wind up as a decent major leaguer for a couple years. I'm surprised
Kansas City let him go, as he could post very interesting numbers in Minnesota's
hitter-friendly AAA park.
Upside/ETA: 1B/3B Reserve. Late-2003.
Quality of pick: Very good.
Los Angeles: Cade Sanchez, RHP, OAK
Brief bio: 24, B:L, T:R. He struck out almost a batter an inning but walked well over a
man for every two strikeouts in relief at high-A Modesto. While he has the stuff to
advance to higher levels, I have significant questions about his command. He's at least
a few years away from solidly contributing in the upper minors.
Upside/ETA: Middle relief. 2005.
Quality of pick: Good gamble.
Oakland: Sonny Garcia, RHP, BAL
Brief bio: 24, B:R, T:R. While he was a little old for his competition, Garcia pitched
lights-out the entire season. He posted a 139:33 K:BB in 143 IP at high-A Frederick
before a 21:9 K:BB mark in 28.1 IP over 5 starts at AA Bowie. While he needs a little
more development time, I see no reason why he can't compete for a rotation spot as soon
as 2003 if he succeeds in Oakland's minors. How does Baltimore let this guy go when they
desperately need to add more prospects?
Upside/ETA: Middle-rotation starter. 2004.
Quality of pick: Excellent.
San Francisco: Aaron Nieckula, C, OAK
Brief bio: 24, B:R, T:R. He doesn't really have enough tools to have significant success
in the upper minors, and his plate discipline is weak enough where he didn't really fit
in with Oakland's system. He could eventually contribute as a backup, but needs several
more years of experience first.
Upside/ETA: Backup catcher. Late-2006.
Quality of pick: Questionable.
Seattle: Dominic Woody, C, FLO
Brief bio: 22, B:R, T:R. Aside from some marginally decent defense, he's done very little
in two years at low-A Kane County of the Midwest League. Florida selected him in the
4th round of the 1999 draft from the University of Washington, so maybe returning to his
hometown organization will inspire Woody to improve his level of play.
Upside/ETA: AAA defensive catcher without significant improvement. 2005.
Quality of pick: Acceptable.
St. Louis: Juan Mejia, RHP, SD
Brief bio: He didn't really show much in 2001 at the lowest levels of the minors, so I'm
not sure why the Cardinals expect future success from him. No other biographical
information is available at this time.
Upside/ETA:
Quality of pick: Questionable.
Triple A Round Three
Los Angeles: Justin Dunning, RHP, NYM
Brief bio: 24, B:R, T:R. Dunning was moved to relief in high-A, and while he retained his
K/IP ratio, his walks increased to give him a 64/62/65.1 K/BB/IP ratio. I'd let him start
again since he appears too wild in relief to show much improvement.
Upside/ETA: Long relief. 2006.
Quality of pick: Acceptable
Seattle: Jason Lakman, RHP, BAL
Brief bio: 24, B:R, T:R. Lakman showed some pitching talent this year, but didn't post
overly impressive ratios and was hit hard at every level. He's historically done better
as a starter than in relief, so I hope the Mariners make room for him in their AA rotation
to see if their gamble pays off.
Upside/ETA: Long relief. Mid-2004.
Quality of pick: Solid.
Triple A Round Four
Los Angeles: Randy Leek, LHP, DET
Brief bio: 24, B:L, T:L. Leek posted some very impressive numbers for AA Erie with a
123:27 K:BB ratio in 179.1 IP. His lack of dominance will keep him from an extremely
successful career, but he certainly can contribute at the major league level.
Upside/ETA: Bottom-of-rotation starter/swingman. Late-2003.
Quality of pick: Very good.
Seattle: Jay Pecci, SS, OAK
Brief bio: 24, B:S, T:R. After losing 4 players in the major league phase of the Rule
Five draft, including Jason Grabowski to Oakland, Seattle gets revenge by swiping Pecci
from the deep Oakland system. He has solid plate discipline with a little power and
speed, as well as the ability to play all around the infield. While he won't spend a
significant amount of time in the majors, he could replace McLemore as a utility guy in
one or two years.
Upside/ETA: Primary utility infielder. Mid-2003.
Quality of pick: Solid.
Double A Round One
Texas: Darin Moore, RHP, OAK
Brief bio: 24, B:R, T:R. He's had absolutely awful command in two stints at high-A ball,
posting both a strikeout and walk per inning of work. Texas is gambling that his stuff
is good enough to mature at a slower rate, and he might have some success in low-A ball
in lieu of Oakland's forced advancement (due to their lack of a low-A team). I'd like to
have seen more control at this point, but he's young enough where he could mature into a
decent pitcher.
Upside/ETA: Too soon to tell.
Quality of pick: Good.
Anaheim: Rocky Hughes, LHP, CHW
Brief bio: 22, B:L, T:L. He has nice numbers the last two years in Rookie ball, but
didn't have a good year at all in 2001 at both levels of A-ball. His K/9 was relatively
poor, and he walked almost as many batters as the struck out. He's a long-term project
with minimal upside at this point.
Upside/ETA: AAA reliever. Mid-2005
Quality of pick: Acceptable.
Seattle: Jason Pruitt, LHP, BAL
Brief bio: 20, B:L, T:L. He's shown very little in four years at the lowest minor league
levels, and I hope Seattle will take their time advancing him. There's definitely a
smidgen of skill here, but the odds aren't great of translating Gulf Coast League success
all the way up the ladder.
Upside/ETA: Too soon to tell.
Quality of pick: Acceptable.
Boston: Yoiset Valle, LHP, CHW
Brief bio: 23, B:L, T:L. He's pitched very little over the last three years with injuries,
and while he's had some success in the Sally league, he needs to get more reps at higher
levels before we'll know his upside.
Upside/ETA: Too soon to tell.
Quality of pick: Good.
Chicago White Sox: Denny Wagner, RHP, OAK
Brief bio: 24, B:R, T:R. Wagner had a very good year in a demotion to A-ball. He's had
solid success twice in the California League, but needs to keep challenging himself in AA
to prove his prospect status. He doesn't rack up that many strikeouts, leaving him very
dependent on solid command.
Upside/ETA: AAA starter. 2004.
Quality of pick: Good.
Chicago Cubs: John Powers, 2B, SD
Brief bio: 27, B:L, T:R. He should have played at AAA this year, but now needs to return
to AA for a third consecutive year until he proves himself again to warrant a AAA trip.
He has good plate discipline and solid doubles' power, along with relatively consistent
defensive ability at 2B and 3B.
Upside/ETA: Benchwarmer in the majors or AAA starter. 2004.
Quality of pick: Good.
Arizona: Daniel Martinez, LHP, CHW
Brief bio: 22, B:L, T:L. Martinez has put up perfectly acceptable numbers in only 50 IP
over the last three years in short-season ball. If he has good potential, he doesn't
have enough stats to show it.
Upside/ETA: Too soon to tell.
Quality of pick: Acceptable.
St. Louis: Jeffrey Brooks, 3B, ARI
Brief bio: 21, B:R, T:R. He's shown no plate discipline in five minor league season, and
his only power displays have occurred in great hitters' parks. I see no real skills that
would enable him to find success at higher levels, so I'm again not quite sure what the
Cardinals were thinking with this pick.
Upside/ETA: AA 3B. 2004.
Quality of pick: Very questionable.
A brief summary of where we're headed: First Basemen Week starts tomorrow, and we'll likely
be discussing major league players non-stop for the next two weeks. I'd like to cover
National Leaguers without a position and AL DHs next Sunday, and then we'll head right into
two weeks of outfield coverage. The rest of January and beginning of February will be
spent working our way through all the pitchers, leading right into projection discussions
as Pitchers and Catchers report to spring training.
Today's Fantasy Rx: Think about your infield. 1B, whether you're spending $40 or
$15, is a lot easier to fill than the other positions, and you now have enough information
to plan much of your activity. We're already formulating our probable keeper lists and
trade targets, and we'll update our files about every week until February. If you think
you see a sleeper, go out and make a trade right now, especially if you think a trade
will open up a position for someone.
Click
here to read the previous article.